How to Check a Seattle SEO Agency's Results and Reviews Before You Hire

A top Seattle SEO agency should be able to show you results you can check: case studies with a dated baseline, the time period, what they did, and what didn't work; references you can call; and Google reviews from businesses like yours that describe the work. Be wary of results that can't be verified — screenshots without dates, rankings for terms nobody searches, or traffic numbers without leads.
What does a credible SEO case study include?
Look for all six:
The client type (even if the name is withheld): industry, size, market.
A starting baseline with a date: leads, calls, organic traffic, or rankings before work began.
The time period: results over six or twelve months, not a single good week.
What was done: specific work, not "we optimized everything."
Business outcomes: calls, form leads, bookings — not just traffic or rankings.
The limits: what didn't change, what else was happening, what the numbers don't show.
The sixth is rare, and it's the most trustworthy signal. An agency that names what its results don't prove is less likely to be stretching the rest. Our own published case study includes a section on exactly that.
What results can't be verified?
Ranking screenshots without the search term, location, date, or search volume.
"Page one for 500 keywords" — often long-tail terms nobody searches.
Traffic graphs with no axis labels or with spikes from unrelated sources.
"300% growth" with no starting number. Growing from 10 to 40 visits is 300%.
Logos of famous clients without a description of the work.
Ask about any of these: "What was the starting number? Which terms? Over what period? What happened to leads?"
How should you read an agency's Google reviews?
Specificity: "Rebuilt our service pages and fixed our Google profile; calls from search went up over six months" beats "Great team!!"
Business type: reviews from businesses like yours count most.
Recency: a steady flow over time, not a burst.
Length of relationship: clients who stayed a year or more say more than first-month praise.
Replies: how the agency responds to critical reviews.
Also check Clutch, Yelp, and Facebook if the agency is listed. A pattern of identical-sounding five-star reviews in a short period is a warning sign.
Should you call references?
Yes, at least one, and ideally a client who's been with them for over a year. Ask:
What did they do in the first three months?
How did reporting work? Did it show leads or just rankings?
What didn't go well, and how did they handle it?
Would you hire them again?
Did you keep ownership of your accounts?
What should a local SEO agency in Seattle be able to show?
For local SEO specifically, ask for examples of:
Google Business Profile performance over time: calls, direction requests, website clicks.
Map pack visibility across a client's service area, not just one search from their office.
Local pages they wrote that rank for "[service] in [neighborhood or city]."
Review growth and response practices.
And ask how they report it monthly.
What claims should end the conversation?
Guaranteed first-page or top-three rankings.
Guaranteed lead counts.
"We have a special relationship with Google."
Refusal to explain what they'll do because it's "proprietary."
No access to your own Search Console and analytics data.
Google itself says no one can guarantee a top ranking. An agency that does is either redefining "ranking" or hoping you won't check. More in marketing agency pricing red flags.
How do you compare two agencies with different-looking results?
Normalize them:
Same type of business as yours?
Similar starting point?
Similar budget?
Measured in leads or calls, not just traffic?
An agency with modest, well-documented results for businesses like yours is a better bet than one with dramatic, unverified claims for businesses unlike yours. For the overall selection process, see how to choose the best digital marketing agency in Seattle.
Key Takeaways
Credible case studies show a dated baseline, the period, the work, business outcomes, and limits.
Ask for starting numbers and search terms behind every ranking or traffic claim.
Read reviews for specifics, recency, business type, and relationship length.
Call at least one long-term reference.
Walk away from guaranteed rankings or results.
Frequently Asked Questions
How can I tell if an SEO agency's results are real?
Ask for the baseline, dates, specific search terms, and business outcomes such as calls and leads behind each claim, and call a reference. Real results come with context and can survive follow-up questions.
What should a local SEO case study include?
The type of business, a dated starting point, the time period, the specific work done, outcomes like calls and leads, and the limits of what the results prove.
Are Google reviews of marketing agencies reliable?
They're useful when they're specific, recent, spread over time, and from businesses like yours. Be cautious of bursts of short, similar five-star reviews.
Can an SEO agency guarantee top rankings in Seattle?
No. Search engines control rankings, and Google says no one can guarantee a top position. Treat any guarantee as a red flag.
Want to See Our Work, Limits Included?
Watt Consulting publishes its case studies with the baseline, the window and what the numbers don't show. See our case study.



Comments